Monday, January 22, 2007

Porter response

I like the narrative form of this essay. I wondered, however, if "the importance of social networks and personal help" (381) that Porter says contributed greatly to his writing development (the loss of which he somewhat laments) was merely a coincidence of the environment he found himself in at the time. For instance, we have all had classes/work situations where a communal atmosphere develops; then, we move into what we hope will be a similar situation, and it's not. This scenario may not make perfect sense, but I'm wondering if we have no choice but to move into a new way of "bonding," so to speak (computer mediated, of course). I guess I prefer to look at the up-side of Internet/computer-based writing, agreeing with his statement that "[Internet} writing [is] an action ...having a dramatic, even revolutionary impact on writing" (386). I did notice that his notes were rather "confessional," and perhaps ancillary to an academic article. This made me wonder if the academic writing genre is changing, slightly, to reflect our real life practices which include e-discourse. Maybe someone who knows much more about the academic writing style can comment on that. Thanks!

2 comments:

mrehill said...

I too enjoyed Porter's narrative style in his article. Not terribly insightful commentary by me, but I thought I'd share. No one posted a comment and this post seemed lonely. Anyway, as for your question of whether or not academic writing is changing stylistically, I am not too sure. Certainly I have noticed the use of "I" in academic discourse more. Possibly this is also a reflection of a "confessional" tone that is inflitrating academia; internet based writing working its way into the academy. There you go.

Tira said...

Thank you! Thank you! thank you! I HATE being alone out in cyberspace, though I knew my original posting was not highly provacative. I was just, you know, trying out this new blog thing! At any rate, I appreciate kind souls and I try, though I don't always succeed, to be one myself!